A group of countries from Europe, Africa, Latin America, and the Pacific has challenged the proposed COP31 agreement, demanding explicit action on fossil fuels and stronger climate finance. As the summit prepares to close on Friday in Antalya, tensions are rising as activists warn the talks are headed for failure while negotiators attempt to find a deal acceptable to nearly 200 governments.
During a press conference on Friday, countries that do not usually negotiate together stood side by side to tell the COP31 Presidency that the agreement on the table is not good enough. Led by France and Panama, the group included representatives from Belgium, Côte d’Ivoire, Finland, Greece, Guatemala, Spain, Sweden, and Vanuatu.
France's Minister for Ecological Transition, Monique Barbut, stated, “We cannot [tell] the world we are now getting to 1.5 [degrees of warming] and then do business as if nothing was happening.” Barbut argued that the climate crisis is a question of survival rather than a "North" or "South" issue. She also highlighted a contradiction in the second draft of the agreement, noting that while fossil fuels are absent, several paragraphs promote carbon capture technologies. “So what does it mean? It means we don’t recognize what is the problem,” Barbut said.
Panama’s Environment Minister, Juan Carlos Navarro, announced earlier this week that his country would formally object to any COP31 agreement that fails to include fossil fuels language. Because UN climate summit decisions are generally adopted by consensus, Navarro's warning could delay or derail the final deal. “It is not acceptable to have a COP or a cover document that does not even mention fossil fuels, and we simply will not put up with it,” Navarro said. He added, “You pollute; you pay. It’s actually rather simple. You cause the problem, you must help to fix it.”
The countries outlined six priorities for the COP31 agreement:
Science: Ensure that climate decisions are firmly grounded in scientific evidence.
Fossil fuels: Explicitly recognize the need for a clear and orderly transition away from fossil fuels.
Climate finance: Require those most responsible for emissions to contribute fairly to financing climate action.
Clean electrification: Accelerate the shift towards electricity generated from renewable, clean energy sources.
Methane: Speed up reductions in methane emissions.
International cooperation: Strengthen coordination between the three Rio Conventions on climate change, biodiversity, and desertification.
These disputes follow warnings from UN Secretary-General António Guterres, who told leaders in Antalya last week that governments must accelerate the transition away from fossil fuels, protect workers, and deliver promised climate finance to developing countries. Guterres called for adaptation funding to triple by 2035 and urged governments to tax windfall profits from fossil fuel companies, insisting, "Polluters must pay."
By Friday afternoon, the COP31 Presidency had not published a new version of the proposed Antalya Accord, leaving delegations to work from Thursday's draft. Activists expressed growing frustration. Representatives from the Climate Action Network (CAN) stood behind speakers with signs spelling “shame,” rejecting the proposed agreements.
CAN International Executive Director Tasneem Essop said, “There is nothing on the table that protects people or addresses the priorities of the Global South." Campaigners accused wealthy countries of blocking progress on finance, emissions reductions, and mechanisms to support workers and communities during the transition to cleaner economies.
Mohamed Adow, founder of Power Shift Africa, stated, “The COP Presidents want to tell us this has been a great COP. Well, I can tell you without any doubt that this has been the worst COP ever.” He accused developed countries of demanding greater ambition while withholding necessary support. Anabella Rosemberg, CAN Senior Adviser on Just Transition, defended the importance of the UN process, stating the COP is being killed because it is the last space where civil society and developing countries can hold developed countries accountable.






