Federal Minister for Climate Change and Environmental Coordination Dr Musadik Malik has criticised the international climate finance system for failing to meet its commitments. Speaking at a session on debt-stressed, climate-vulnerable economies at the Pakistan Pavilion during COP31, Malik argued that developing countries cannot meet climate targets or rebuild after disasters through additional borrowing when a substantial share of their revenue is consumed by debt servicing.
Malik stated that international assistance to developing countries declined by 23 per cent in a single year, returning to 2015 levels despite repeated global pledges to increase funding. He questioned the credibility of these commitments, noting that ambitious financial targets have not translated into actual assistance. “We have been talking about increasing climate finance, but assistance to developing countries has gone down by 23 per cent in one year,” Malik said.
The minister dismissed the promotion of green bonds, blended finance, and green sukuk as debt instruments rather than additional resources. “All these fancy words — green sukuk, blended finance, green bonds — these are debt instruments. Our shop is closed for debt,” Malik said. He noted that of the approximately Rs16 trillion in revenue Pakistan collected, Rs8 trillion went toward debt servicing, leaving little fiscal space for development.
Malik highlighted the 2022 floods, stating reconstruction costs reached around nine per cent of the country’s gross domestic product. He claimed the international response consisted largely of $8 billion to $10 billion in repurposed loans, which forced the redirection of funds originally intended for health and education. He noted that the previous five major floods in Pakistan resulted in around 6,000 deaths, 20,000 injuries or disabilities, and affected or displaced 40 million people.
The minister also questioned the fairness of global financing, citing that 10 countries account for 70 per cent of greenhouse gas emissions but received 80 per cent of green finance. “Financing is chasing emissions, not vulnerability, not death, not morbidity, not mortality,” Malik said. He further questioned the Loss and Damage Fund, stating that while $822 million had been pledged and $422 million collected, no money had reached affected communities since the fund's creation.
Despite these challenges, Malik reported that Pakistan has accelerated its clean energy transition through domestic investment. He stated that citizens and farmers installed an estimated 33 to 37 gigawatts of rooftop solar capacity without substantial international assistance. Clean energy currently accounts for around 55 per cent of Pakistan’s energy mix, with a target of 70 to 75 per cent in the coming years.
Earlier in the session, MNA Dr Nafisa Shah, co-convenor of the Parliamentary Forum on Energy and Economy, described climate-vulnerable communities as being pushed into a “climate-debt trap.” She stated the 2022 floods affected around 33 million people and caused more than $30 billion in losses. “Communities that contributed almost nothing to the climate crisis are being asked to rebuild their lives through additional debt,” Dr Shah said. She called for grants, concessional finance, climate-resilient debt clauses, debt swaps, and improved access to the Loss and Damage Fund.
Minister of State for Climate Change Dr Shezra Mansab Ali Khan Kharal highlighted adaptation initiatives, including 284 early-warning stations supported by the UNDP protecting around 700,000 people in Gilgit-Baltistan and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa. She also noted that more than one million climate-resilient homes were completed for flood-affected families in Sindh, with ownership rights granted to women. Dr Shezra added that the federal Climate Budget Statement has mapped more than 5,000 cost centres for climate-related expenditure.
MNA Danyal Chaudhry, parliamentary secretary for information and broadcasting and secretary of the forum, stated that legislators have a responsibility to translate international climate commitments into national laws and budgetary priorities. The session was organised by the Parliamentary Forum on Energy and Economy in collaboration with the Asian Peoples’ Movement on Debt and Development (APMDD).






