The Policy Research Institute of Market Economy (PRIME) has warned that the Federal Board of Revenue’s (FBR) decision to separate income tax and sales tax administration could encourage businesses to stay outside the tax net and expand Pakistan’s informal economy.

The think tank criticized the government for reversing a 17-year-old reform from 2009. That previous arrangement brought income tax, sales tax, and federal excise collections under the Inland Revenue Service to reduce duplication, improve compliance, and allow a single tax officer to manage a company’s tax affairs.

Last week, the FBR separated sales tax and federal excise administration from income tax within the Inland Revenue Service. Dr. Muhammad Sarmad Qureshi was appointed the first Member of Sales Tax and Federal Excise Duty, while Muhammad Anwar was named chief of these taxes. A separate stream of officers is expected to become operational next month.

PRIME stated that the FBR justified the restructuring by citing weak domestic sales tax collection, which fell by 1.7 percent during the last fiscal year, even though collections at the import stage rose by 17 percent. However, PRIME argued that separating the administrations weakens a mechanism for detecting evasion because businesses report overlapping financial information in both income tax and sales tax returns.

The institute noted that a company hiding sales to lower its sales tax liability might also be hiding income. When one officer handles both taxes, discrepancies in one return can expose evasion in the other. Separate officers could weaken this connection, PRIME said.

PRIME warned that manufacturers, importers, and distributors already registered with the FBR could face two commissioners, separate notices, and different interpretations of the same transactions. Conversely, businesses outside the tax net would avoid these compliance requirements. The institute suggested that increased costs and complexity of registration could discourage businesses from entering the formal economy.

The think tank also argued that fragmented value-added tax administration, where goods are taxed federally and services fall under provincial authorities, is a major obstacle to collection. PRIME stated that a harmonized value-added tax covering both goods and services with a lower unified rate and fewer exemptions would improve revenue more effectively than administrative restructuring.

The institute added that Pakistan’s tax to GDP ratio remained at 10.3 percent during the past two fiscal years despite repeated reforms and billions of dollars in loans.

Other figures highlighted issues within the tax and financial systems. National Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorism Authority (NAML&CTA) Chairman Mushtaq Sukhera told a Senate committee that Pakistan’s reliance on cash transactions is a major driver of illicit financial activity and that a policy paper proposing a transition toward a digital economy had been submitted to the government.

Senator Dilawar Khan cautioned tax authorities against aggressive enforcement that could target legitimate taxpayers, noting that money laundering notices were being issued to individuals and businesses already registered with the FBR. Additionally, Senator Abdul Qadir criticized corruption within the tax administration, citing a recent controversy at the Regional Tax Office in Lahore involving a dispute over the distribution of bribe money.