Justice Asad Ali Bajwa of the Lahore High Court (LHC) has ruled that a privately arranged DNA test cannot override the legal presumption of legitimacy for a child born during a valid marriage. The court dismissed a petition filed by Usama Tahir and others against Zainab Irfan and others, which challenged a maintenance award for a minor son and the recovery of dowry articles.
The court noted that the parties were married on August 18, 2019, and their minor son was born on April 27, 2022, while the marriage was still subsisting. Under Article 128 of the Qanun-e-Shahadat Order, 1984, the court observed that the birth of a child during a valid marriage gives rise to a conclusive presumption of legitimacy, subject to specific legal exceptions.
Usama Tahir disputed the child’s paternity by relying on a DNA report allegedly obtained from a private laboratory in the United Kingdom, which reportedly excluded him as the biological father. However, Justice Bajwa observed that the test was arranged privately by the father without supervision or direction from a competent court. The judge held that such a report could not displace the legal presumption of legitimacy.
"A unilateral DNA test report cannot by itself displace the conclusive presumption of legitimacy provided under Article 128 of the Qanun-i-Shahadat Order, 1984," Justice Bajwa stated.
The judgment emphasized that DNA testing in paternity disputes is a serious judicial matter that must be handled with caution to protect a child’s dignity, privacy, and emotional well-being. The court noted that the DNA test in this case was arranged secretly without the mother’s consent or the court’s permission, raising concerns regarding the privacy, liberty, and bodily autonomy of both the mother and the child.
The court also took into account admissions from the father’s family members during evidence, who admitted the marriage was intact at the time of the child’s birth. Furthermore, the court referred to the Muslim Personal Law (Shariat) Application Act, 1962, and a Supreme Court judgment in Ghazala Tehsin Zohra v. Mehr Ghulam Dastgir Khan, noting that a Muslim father seeking to challenge paternity must do so within a maximum period of 40 days from the child’s birth.
Regarding financial matters, the court upheld an enhanced maintenance award against the father, who lives in the United Kingdom. While Zainab Irfan claimed the father earns Rs1.2 million a month, the court noted she provided no documentary proof. However, the court found support for her claim because the petitioner’s own witnesses admitted he lives in the UK and sends money into a family bank account.
The judge ruled that maintenance depends on the child’s reasonable needs—including food, clothing, lodging, education, and healthcare—and the father’s means. The court also found that the petitioner failed to show any misreading of evidence regarding the award of dowry articles or their alternate value of Rs970,000.






