The Federal Constitutional Court of Pakistan (FCCP) has declared the charge sheet and departmental inquiry against National Accountability Bureau (NAB) Director General Shahzad Saleem illegal. A two-member bench, consisting of Justice Syed Hasan Azhar Rizvi and Justice Muhammad Karim Khan Agha, set aside the proceedings, ruling that matters already examined by the Supreme Court cannot be reopened after two decades without new evidence or legal justification.
The court's judgment also set aside a May 12, 2026, judgment from the Islamabad High Court. In its ruling, the court observed that a violation of recruitment rules alone does not constitute misconduct unless an officer secured an appointment through "fraud, misrepresentation, concealment of facts or corruption."
The court noted that Shahzad Saleem was absorbed into NAB in 2003. It highlighted that questions regarding his qualifications, promotions, and appointment had already been reviewed by the Supreme Court. During those previous proceedings, NAB informed the apex court that Saleem’s master’s degree was verified by the Higher Education Commission (HEC) and that he possessed the necessary qualifications at the time of his appointment.
The FCCP observed that NAB subsequently questioned that same degree and started disciplinary proceedings without providing any new evidence or reasonable justification. The court further noted that an allegation regarding a lack of five years’ experience could not be considered misconduct without a charge of misrepresentation or concealment of facts.
The judgment pointed out that NAB initiated the proceedings based on a private complaint without verifying the identity of the complainant or properly examining its own records and previous submissions made to the Supreme Court. The court distinguished between an appointment made in violation of rules and actual misconduct by an employee, holding that reopening settled matters after an excessive delay was legally unjustified.
As a result, the court declared the October 10, 2024, charge sheet, statement of allegations, and all subsequent departmental proceedings against Shahzad Saleem null and void.






