Key Takeaways
- TV review of 'The Westies' describes it as a flat take on New York’s Irish mob.
- The drama focuses on the construction site where Hillary Clinton conceded the 2016 election.
- Critics find the series unengaging and fails to capture the intrigue of its subject matter.
J.K. Simmons stars in 'The Westies,' a crime drama that has been described as a lackluster portrayal of New York’s Irish mob. The show, produced by MGM+, centers on the construction site where Hillary Clinton conceded the 2016 election, but critics find it fails to deliver the expected level of intrigue and engagement.
In Variety's review, the series is criticized for its flat narrative, stating that 'the construction of the glass box where Hillary Clinton would eventually concede the 2016 election may not sound like the stuff of riveting television. And sure enough, it isn’t — at least in “The Westies.”' The reviewer suggests that the show’s premise lacks the dynamism to sustain viewer interest.
Simmons plays a key role in the series but is unable to elevate the material. 'The Westies' struggles to capture the historical and cultural significance of its setting, instead opting for a straightforward narrative that fails to engage with the complexities of the Irish mob's activities during the 1970s and 1980s.
Critics point out that the series’ focus on the construction site of the Javits Center is not enough to make up for its lack of depth. The show’s inability to delve into the political and social context surrounding the Irish mob's operations further diminishes its appeal, leaving viewers unfulfilled.
While Simmons brings his usual gravitas to the role, it is clear that 'The Westies' relies heavily on its star power without delivering a compelling story. The drama fails to capitalize on the rich history of New York’s Irish mob and instead offers a flat take on an otherwise interesting subject matter.
Overall, 'The Westies' is a disappointment for fans of crime dramas. Its failure to engage with the historical and cultural context of its setting leaves it feeling unremarkable and underwhelming. Critics recommend that viewers approach this series with low expectations, as it does not deliver the level of entertainment or insight one might hope for from a show about such a significant period in New York’s history.
